Curio

State Library of New South Wales

Resolution and Discovery in the Arctic Sea, 1781

Resolution and Discovery in the Arctic Sea, 1781

Thomas Luny (1759–1837)

Oil painting

ML 402


British artist Thomas Luny based this work on sketches by John Webber, expedition artist on Cook’s third voyage. The painting depicts the activities of the Resolution and Discovery in the Arctic Sea between 11 August and 3 September 1778. A Thomas Luny sketchbook held by the National Maritime Museum, Greenwich, contains three preliminary drawings dated 1781 for the painting (the expedition had returned to England in 1780).  


The meaning of ice ...

By TDO Ware, The Meaning of Ice: Scientific scrutiny and the visual record obtained from the British Polar Expeditions between 1772 and 1854, University of Sussex, 2013, p44

The exhibition painting in 1781 by Thomas Luny, 1759 –1793, Resolution and Discovery in the Arctic Sea, is loosely based upon sketches made by John Webber. Luny, who had never seen the Arctic, uses amore positive seascape beset with icebergs which do not accurately match those described by Cook in the Beaufort Sea. The painting puts both these famous ships close to one other sailing easily and with no sign of any immediate danger. This optimistic and commercially acceptable painting combining smooth sea and a beautiful sky uses aquamarine tones in the small waves around the ships, which seem calming and reassuring. The inclusion of some walrus as bystanders watching the ships make passage through the ice to the misty horizon establishes the special interest of humanity in their progress. It is likely to have been painted as a commemorative study following the news of Cook’s unfortunate death in 1779 when his crews returned home.


HMS Resolution

By Doug Gibson, originally published in Cook's Log, page 50, volume 2, number 3 (1977)

The genius of Captain James Cook was readily recognised by the Admiralty after the first great voyage of discovery. Plans were made almost immediately for a second voyage - this time to make a complete circumnavigation in the high Antarctic latitudes.

Cook had very vivid memories of near disaster while sailing through unknown waters and his choice of ships was accepted by the Admiralty who were very conscious of the magnitude of the undertaking.

The Navy Board purchased two vessels, the Marquis of Granby and the Marquis of Rockingham. Both were similar types to the Endeavour but were not really barks or barques. They could have been classed as ship-rigged sloops-of-war and were built by Thomas Fishburn in 1770 at Whitby. They were commissioned under the names of Drake and Raleigh. Lord Rockford, Secretary of State, thought the names might offend the Spanish and consulted both the King and the Earl of Sandwich. The Earl advised him they were to be renamed the Resolution and Adventure.

The Resolution impressed Cook greatly and he called her "the ship of my choice", the fittest for service of any I have seen". She was 14 months old and her tonnage of 462 was 100 more than the Endeavour. She had the same flat-floored, apple-cheeked hull as the Endeavour.

Her dimensions were:

  • Lower deck length:   110 ft 8.inches (33.731m) 
  • Keel:                            093 ft 6.inches (28.499m) 
  • Maximum beam:      035 ft 3 ½ inches (10.757m) 
  • Maximum depth:      013 ft 1 ½ inches (4.0005m)

She was fitted out at Deptford with the most advanced navigational aids of the day, including a Gregory Azimuth Compass, ice anchors and the latest apparatus for distilling fresh water from seawater. Twelve carriage guns and twelve swivel guns were carried. At his own expense Cook had brass door-hinges installed in the great cabin.

The Resolution cost the Admiralty £4,151. It was originally planned that Joseph Banks with an appropriate entourage would sail again with Cook. A heightened waist, an additional upper deck and a raised poop or round house were built to suit Banks, but the ship was found to be top heavy in short sea trials. Under Admiralty instructions, the offending structures were removed. Banks refused to travel under "adverse conditions" and was replaced by Johann Forster and his son, George. The conversion bill had cost a further £6565.

Her complement when she sailed from Plymouth on 13 July 1772 was 112, and this included 20 volunteers from the Endeavour. On her second voyage (Cook's third voyage) she again carried 112.

On his first voyage Cook had calculated longitude by the usual method of lunars but on her second voyage the Board of Longitude spared no expense. It sent William Wales, a highly qualified astronomer, with Cook and entrusted a new chronometer, recently completed by Larcum Kendall (K1), together with three chronometers made by John Arnold of Aldophi. Kendall's K1 was remarkably accurate and was to prove to be most efficient in determining longitude on board the Resolution.

The Resolution was responsible for some remarkable feats and was to prove one of the great ships of history. She was the first ship to cross the Antarctic Circle (17 January 1773) and crossed twice more on the voyage. The third crossing on 3 February 1774, was the deepest penetration: Latitude 71° 10' South, Longitude 106° 54' W. As a consequence the Resolution was instrumental in proving Dalrymple's Terra Australis Incognita (Southern Continent) to be a myth. On his third voyage, Cook in the Resolution crossed the Arctic Circle on 17 August 1778. Charles Clerke, who took over the command after Cook's tragic death again crossed it on 19 July 1779.

The Resolution was back in England in 1780. She was converted into an armed transport and sailed for the East Indies in March 1781. She was captured by De Suffrens squadron on June 9, 1782. His journal states he was joined by the Sylphide and her prize the Resolution, a ship made famous by the voyages of Captain Cook.

After the action at Negapostam, the Resolution was sent to Manila for wood, biscuit and rigging, and to enter any seaman she found there. She sailed on July 22, 1782 and on June 5, 1783 De Suffren expressed a notion that she had either foundered or fallen into the hands of the English and was last seen in the Straits of Sunda. An extract from the Melbourne Argus, February 25, 1879 says that the Resolution ended her days as a Portuguese coal-hulk at Rio de Janeiro, but this is unconfirmed. In the possession of Viscount Galway, a Governor-General of New Zealand, is a ship's figurehead described as that of the Resolution. A photograph of it does not agree with the figurehead depicted in Holman's watercolour.

It was zeal and resolution, which kept Cook at his tasks and helped him surmount so many obstacles. It is so befitting the man that such a noble ship of his choice should have been called the Resolution.

There are 57 stamps issued which depict the Resolution, and there is no doubt this number will be greatly increased by the anniversary of Cook's death. The 1968 Cook Island issue is a beautiful set, but for sheer atmosphere my choice is the 1973 Norfolk Island 35c stamp issued for the Bicentenary of the First Crossing of the Antarctic Circle. It has been adapted from a watercolour by William Hodges.


Thomas Luny

By Falmouth Art Gallery, 2014

Thomas Luny was born on 20th May 1759. It is thought that he was born in the small parish of St Ewe in Cornwall where he was baptised, rather than London as many books suggest. His parents were Thomas and Elizabeth Luny. Soon after his birth the family moved to London and Luny became pupil of the celebrated Thameside artist, Francis Holman, who trained him in the discipline of marine art. 

 In 1780 Luny left Holman and set himself up in Anchor Hope Street. He painted a large number of works depicting ships of the East India Company, and later works showing naval battle scenes. Many of these were probably commissioned by the ship captains. As a result of his extensive knowledge of rigging and other marine details it has been suggested that Luny may have been taken by the Royal Navy as a guest to record certain maritime events or even that he might have enlisted in the Merchant Service. However, neither of these theories has been confirmed. 

 In 1807 Luny moved to Teignmouth, Devon where he remained for the rest of his life. The move was probably made for health reasons as he suffered from arthritis in his hands. Also many of his ex-mariner friends had retired there. 

 Eventually his arthritis confined him to a wheelchair and affected his hands so he had to hold his brush between both hands or strapped to his wrist. Even so he produced over 2,200 paintings between 1807 and 1835. He died on 30th September 1837 and was buried in West Teignmouth Churchyard.